Top 50ish P4P 1960-Present

[SCtrojansbaby]

My system

50% resume
25% ability
25% longevity

Tier1

Roy Jones Jr
Muhammad Ali
Carlos Monzon
Sugar Ray Leonard
Julio Cesar Chavez

Tier2

Mike McCallum Manny Pacquiao
Roberto Duran
Roman Gonzalez
Bernard Hopkins
Floyd Mayweather Jr
Michael Spinks
Wilfredo Gomez
Evaded Holyfield

Tier3

George Foreman
Fighting Harada
Marco Antonio Barrera
Lennox Lewis
Salvador Sanchez
Oleksandr Usyk
Emile Griffith
Eder Jofre
Andre Ward
Nonito Donaire
Jeff Fenech
Finito Lopez

Tier4

Rueben Olivares
Rafael Marquez
Juan Estrada
Canelo Alvarez
Juan Manuel Marquez
Jose Napoles
Winky Wright
Marvin Hagler
Felix Trinidad
James Toney
Alexis Arguello
Thomas Hearns
Erik Morales
Shane Mosley
Chris Eubank
Aaron Pryor
Sot Chilada
Joe Frazier
Larry Holmes
Azumah Nelson
Miguel Canto
Bob Foster
Pernell Whitaker
Humberto Gonzalez
**** Tiger
Naoya Inoue

Flame away...

[DeeMoney]

Duran needs to be tier 1- had a great run at Lightweight in the 70s, and beating prime SRL at SRL's best weight is arguably the best win ever. Later had good longevity throughout the 80s

Hagler and Hearns should be higher, though thats just my criteria, but I cant find a way to have them below Jeff Fenech, Nonito Donaire, and Fighting Harada.

Ditto for Pernell Whittaker

Id probably agree on 45 of the names being top 50, without actually doing a list right now.

[QueensburyRules]

- - Your Tier 2 Manny fought, whooped and otherwise knocked out more Ring P4Pers in history so much that nobody is even close.

Most years both divisionally and P4P ranked and most consecutive years in those categories

And he did it almost exclusively as the away fighter.

Me thinks you need a new system.